My suggestion is very simple. I think, we should not give away the gold from the treasury, until we hit some minimum. A recommend this gold amount to be 5000 gold. Until we hit this, I recommend that the gold should stay in the clan stash.
I agree we should have a minimum amount of gold in the treasure, but 5000 gold is a lot. I mean, if we do regular Clan Wars from now on, I think we should start building it up slowly, while also giving some out to the members. This is to prevent people form getting demotivated as the gold they "earn" stays in the treasury.
Since I think we'll probably participate in nearly every season from now on, we should start saving maybe 1500 or 2000 gold and give out the rest. The next season we do the same and gradually increase the treasury, while also not forgetting about the members who helped in CW ^^
We could always agree that if the gold hits a certain value in treasury, every member gets some extra bonus as opposed to setting some aside for treasury each week.
I hope I explained it properly, it was hard to put this idea in words
I kinda agree about this with Xeno, 5000 is just way too much and that will demotivate those who are in this just for the gold and motivate a quick snatch & grab for those that can get to it...just kiddin'
While i do understand that we need to save some gold for the clan for prizes for fun events and such (or whatever Fail & ya gents come up with) we could tax some small ammount of gold that we can get from CW every day. I don't mind even if it would be a daily tax (10-20% from what we get daily goes straight to clan) or something like it? I know and am well aware that this way it takes longer for the bank to fill up, but i suppose there won't be as much complaints then?
Just my two cents into this, idk if it's a good idea or not but atleast it should be quite fair of an idea
Last Edit: Aug 24, 2015 19:00:07 GMT by DreamOnFin
"Sometimes, you need to jump into the battlefield even if it seems like you'll surely die" - Pico / RF4
Just to clear misunderstanding. I don't want to keep this gold. I thought about that after we hit 5000 gold, then we give out that 5000 gold to the players who helped.
Just to clear misunderstanding. I don't want to keep this gold. I thought about that after we hit 5000 gold, then we give out that 5000 gold to the players who helped.
No worries, I don't think there ever was one though...i did get what ya meant
I know that the payment ammounts for CW players will be smaller this way what i suggested in, but i'd rather get paid from the work we do right away than wait for some undisclosed time for the bank to fill up and then pay, which could allso lead to misunderstandings and we might even accidentaly forget to pay someone who has participated in CW. Of course i'm not saying that this could happen, but this minimizes the chances of such even happening in the first place.
Besides that, i'd like that even the clan gets some gold as well for whatever fun events/events we come up with that doesn't get shared right away. That's why i thought about the daily tax system, i know it's more PITA-work for the one who handles clan treasury, but it should be quite fair for all and be a win-win for both sides, participating players get paid & clan gets gold for it's treasury for whatever we come up with it eventually.
Just throwing more cents into this discussion, if anyone has more ideas about this then share them as well
"Sometimes, you need to jump into the battlefield even if it seems like you'll surely die" - Pico / RF4
Just to clear misunderstanding. I don't want to keep this gold. I thought about that after we hit 5000 gold, then we give out that 5000 gold to the players who helped.
No worries, I don't think there ever was one though...i did get what ya meant
I know that the payment ammounts for CW players will be smaller this way what i suggested in, but i'd rather get paid from the work we do right away than wait for some undisclosed time for the bank to fill up and then pay, which could allso lead to misunderstandings and we might even accidentaly forget to pay someone who has participated in CW. Of course i'm not saying that this could happen, but this minimizes the chances of such even happening in the first place.
Besides that, i'd like that even the clan gets some gold as well for whatever fun events/events we come up with that doesn't get shared right away. That's why i thought about the daily tax system, i know it's more PITA-work for the one who handles clan treasury, but it should be quite fair for all and be a win-win for both sides, participating players get paid & clan gets gold for it's treasury for whatever we come up with it eventually.
Just throwing more cents into this discussion, if anyone has more ideas about this then share them as well
This was actually what I was thinking too, keep some gold for events, distribute the rest evenly on a weekly (?) base. Also if for example someone leaves YATTA and they helped in CW, they wouldn't have received their share of the gold. Just on of the example of things that could go wrong with saving up everything ^^
No worries, I don't think there ever was one though...i did get what ya meant
I know that the payment ammounts for CW players will be smaller this way what i suggested in, but i'd rather get paid from the work we do right away than wait for some undisclosed time for the bank to fill up and then pay, which could allso lead to misunderstandings and we might even accidentaly forget to pay someone who has participated in CW. Of course i'm not saying that this could happen, but this minimizes the chances of such even happening in the first place.
Besides that, i'd like that even the clan gets some gold as well for whatever fun events/events we come up with that doesn't get shared right away. That's why i thought about the daily tax system, i know it's more PITA-work for the one who handles clan treasury, but it should be quite fair for all and be a win-win for both sides, participating players get paid & clan gets gold for it's treasury for whatever we come up with it eventually.
Just throwing more cents into this discussion, if anyone has more ideas about this then share them as well
This was actually what I was thinking too, keep some gold for events, distribute the rest evenly on a weekly (?) base. Also if for example someone leaves YATTA and they helped in CW, they wouldn't have received their share of the gold. Just on of the example of things that could go wrong with saving up everything ^^
Ohohoh, I so like to do this, a big round of applause for you:D
Of course, it was only a suggestion. I will not be one to decide anyway, but I do see your point.
Just posting it here, because i have no idea where is a better place. I resign all of my potential gold earnings in favour of the clan treasury as i would rather see it used as a special gift for a MVP of any given time period, or other important things that the treasury keeper deems more worthy, like special gifts to our glorious leaders so that everyone could be spared from their wrath from time to time
Eat and sleep whenever you can, because one can never know when it will be possible again.
Not a real quote but deeply inspired by works from Erich Maria Remarque